American Special Operations: Past, Present, And Future – Modern War Institute

Excerpts:
This is what most people think of when they hear the term “special operations,” elite forces swooping in snatching a target and swooping back out again before anyone knows they were there. Whole Redbox machines could be filled with movies that have plot lines with special operators as the heroes—steely-eyed killers, super soldiers, whose missions are classified at levels above Top Secret.
 
But as author Mark Moyar describes in his new book Oppose Any Foe, special operations hasn’t always enjoyed the notoriety it has today. In fact, by reading his book you will soon learn the opposite is true, that American special operations forces of today were born out of failure and adversity. It’s a true testament to the perseverance of the proponents of special operations that they are even available to be so heavily relied on today.
As Moyar moves through the history of special operations in Korea and Vietnam the same pattern arises: a special operations unit is stood up, said unit is perceived to be stealing the best and most reliable soldiers, failures happen, the unit is slammed by high-level decision-makers, and the unit is either disbanded or pushed into relative obscurity.
The roles and missions of special operations forces must also be clearly defined. Surgical strikes—while US special operations forces have conducted them repeatedly and largely with precision and effectiveness in America’s most recent wars—are not the only types of operations that they are trained for and ready to execute. Special operations units are generally broken up into two categories. “Black SOF,” consisting of Delta Force, SEAL Team 6, and similar units, are responsible for the type surgical strikes described above, while “White SOF,”—everyone else—are responsible for things like advising foreign forces. The focus on surgical strikes in recent conflicts have forced “White SOF” to shift some of their focus to keep up with the frenetic operational pace. Moyar argues that these special operations units must get back to the basics of training foreign partners. The demand for this type of training is already there, but it will require support from the State Department for approvals.
 
The basics are not simply training foreign forces. The basics are conducting unconventional warfare and foreign internal defense to achieve strategic aims.  Advising and assisting indigenous forces are an inherent task and skill within these missions but training foreign forces is a means to an end and not an end itself.

American Special Operations: Past, Present, And Future – Modern War Institute

mwi.usma.edu · by James King · July 6, 2017

Mark Moyar, Oppose Any Foe: The Rise of America’s Special Operations Forces (Basic Books, 2017)

The target, a high-level leader in a terrorist organization that intelligence has indicated is plotting to execute a major attack in the United States, had no idea what was about to happen. High above, and several dozen kilometers to the east of his family’s compound, the red light next to the open ramp of a C-130 turns green and a team of SEALs dives out. Their steerable, rectangular, chutes open almost immediately as the team members execute an almost perfect High Altitude/High Opening (HAHO) jump. If the target were to look up he might be able to make out the faint specks floating in the night air. Unfortunately for him he is asleep and totally unaware of what is about to happen to him.

The team lands a few kilometers away from the objective. They stash their equipment, link up, and move silently towards the target, where they cordon off the compound. The breach team affixes a small explosive and detonates it. The assault team moves in almost as fast as the debris from the explosion. The target is found, bound, and separated from the rest of his family as the sound of helicopter blades chewing up the air can be heard getting louder in the distance.

The team is only waiting a few minutes for the retrieval aircraft to arrive but in that time they have searched every room, exploiting the site—rounding up as many documents and as much computer hardware that they can find. Once the Blackhawks arrive, kicking up a cloud of dust as they come in, the team moves out of the compound with the target and aboard the aircraft. They are gone almost as fast as they arrived, leaving the target and his family to wonder what just happened.

This is what most people think of when they hear the term “special operations,” elite forces swooping in snatching a target and swooping back out again before anyone knows they were there. Whole Redbox machines could be filled with movies that have plot lines with special operators as the heroes—steely-eyed killers, super soldiers, whose missions are classified at levels above Top Secret.

But as author Mark Moyar describes in his new book Oppose Any Foe, special operations hasn’t always enjoyed the notoriety it has today. In fact, by reading his book you will soon learn the opposite is true, that American special operations forces of today were born out of failure and adversity. It’s a true testament to the perseverance of the proponents of special operations that they are even available to be so heavily relied on today.

In the first half of the book Moyar discusses the beginnings of US special operations in World War II. The stories of the Army Rangers, Navy Frogmen, Marine Raiders, and a combined United States and Canadian element known as the Forcemen have a similar feel. Except for the Navy Frogmen, each of these forces were used in both successful unconventional and less-than-successful conventional roles and were ultimately disbanded.

A prime example of this dichotomy is the story of the Army Rangers. The Rangers enjoyed some initial success in an unconventional role supporting Operation Torch, the invasion of North Africa. During that operation they were tasked with seizing the port of Arzew on the Algerian coast. Taking the town quietly would spare it from a bombardment by naval gunfire and preserve the facilities for use by Allied forces. The Rangers were successful in sneaking up on the Vichy French contingent, seizing the two forts that surrounded the port while losing only two soldiers in the process.

With that success in the books, Moyar explains that the temptation arose to use the Rangers in all manners of missions. While supporting operations in and around Salerno, Gen. Mark Clark decided to split up the Ranger battalions and attach them to conventional units in an attempt to break the Germans’ Winter Line. This re-tasking angered leadership in the Rangers, who thought “it squandered the specialized capabilities they had toiled months, if not years, to develop.” Their protests fell on deaf ears. Gen. Clark believed “keeping special units in reserve until the need for special missions arose was a luxury that he could not afford.” His belief stemmed from the situation he found himself in: it was so bad he was even pulling musicians out of bands as replacements.

The decision was a disastrous one for the Rangers. They lost almost half their formation to casualties, with many more Rangers sent to the rear for what would be called PTSD today. This left gaping holes in Ranger units, which were filled with soldiers who were not of the same caliber as the initial set of troops, reducing their effectiveness even further. While they would go on to be given one of the hardest missions of D-Day, scaling the cliffs of Pointe du Hoc, their use during special missions was few and far between for the rest of the war.

The Ranger battalions would not survive World War II. All of them would be disbanded at the end of the war. They would not return to active service until 1974 when then Army Chief of Staff, Gen. Creighton Abrams would direct the formation of a Ranger battalion. That battalion and two others remain active to this day.

As Moyar moves through the history of special operations in Korea and Vietnam the same pattern arises: a special operations unit is stood up, said unit is perceived to be stealing the best and most reliable soldiers, failures happen, the unit is slammed by high-level decision-makers, and the unit is either disbanded or pushed into relative obscurity.

While the early chapters of Moyar’s book do a fine job of getting their points across, the scope of the material is so expansive that the level of detail feels lacking in some areas. It’s not until Moyar gets into the more modern conflicts of Iraq and Afghanistan that he fine-tunes his focal point and delves deeper and more satisfyingly into the operations he describes. The emphasis on details in the last few chapters does not, however, change the theme of the early chapters—that US special operations forces exist despite failures. These failures come with familiar names like Desert One, Blackhawk Down, and Operation Anaconda.

To conclude his book Moyar provides some thoughts on how special operations might best move forward. He argues that the first key to future success is support and leadership from the president. He makes the case that only one president, John F. Kennedy, has truly supported special operations. And presidents of the future, if they are like presidents of the past, “will be prone to making decisions on the sizes and activities of special operations forces based on superficial and romanticized views of those forces.” These temptations, he concludes, must be resisted.

The roles and missions of special operations forces must also be clearly defined. Surgical strikes—while US special operations forces have conducted them repeatedly and largely with precision and effectiveness in America’s most recent wars—are not the only types of operations that they are trained for and ready to execute. Special operations units are generally broken up into two categories. “Black SOF,” consisting of Delta Force, SEAL Team 6, and similar units, are responsible for the type surgical strikes described above, while “White SOF,”—everyone else—are responsible for things like advising foreign forces. The focus on surgical strikes in recent conflicts have forced “White SOF” to shift some of their focus to keep up with the frenetic operational pace. Moyar argues that these special operations units must get back to the basics of training foreign partners. The demand for this type of training is already there, but it will require support from the State Department for approvals.

The most important of Moyar’s conclusion is the need he highlights for special operations forces to have a good relationship with conventional forces. In both Iraq and Afghanistan, many conventional force commanders have had a negative view of special operations, who they perceive to swoop into a unit’s area of operation, conduct a raid, depart without letting anyone know they were there, and leave the conventional force to clean up any mess that was made. In a near-peer force-on-force fight, this would have vastly more consequential effects, so special operations and conventional forces must be able to work together in a mutually supporting environment.

Ultimately, if someone is looking for a book that sings the praises of special operations or one that focuses solely on sexy, Hollywood-style secret missions they won’t find it here. Moyar pulls no punches in his examination of both the successes and failures of special operations and their implications on the US military as a whole. What they will find is a book that is a well-researched starting point from which to better understand special operations—past, present, and future.

Image credit: Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Michael B.W. Watkins, US Navy

mwi.usma.edu · by James King · July 6, 2017

167 comments

  1. cbd vape http://cbdoilrx.us.com/ – cbd for sale hemp cbd cbd hemp

  2. cbd capsules http://cbdoilrx.us.com/ – cbd oil cbd pure buy cbd

  3. cbd products cbd cream cbd oil store

  4. cdb oils hemp cbd buy cbd oil online

  5. hemp cbd cbd oil for pain best cbd oil buy cbd oil

  6. cbd medic cdb oils buy cbd oil

  7. cbd online cbd tinctures cbd oil online cbd oil for pain

  8. hemp cbd oil cbd vape cbd oil online medterra cbd

  9. cbd vape http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd oil store cbd oil for pain cbd pills

  10. cbd vape http://cbdoilstore.us.com/ – cbd pills cbd oil at walmart cbd oil online

  11. best cbd oil buy hemp oil buy cbd oil online

  12. cbd oil benefits http://cbdoilrx.us.com/ – best cbd oil buy cbd oil cbd oil benefits buy cbd oil online

  13. cbd gummies hemp oil cbd oil cbd capsules

  14. best cbd oil buy cbd oil http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd pills cbd products cbd online

  15. cbd gummies walmart cbd oil online buy cbd cbd products

  16. buy cbd hemp cbd hemp oil for pain pure cbd oil

  17. cbd oil store buy cbd oil online cbd for sale cbd medic

  18. cbd pure cbd vape cbd drops cbd gummies walmart

  19. cbd drops cbd pure cbd near me

  20. cbd cream http://cbdoilrx.us.com/ – hemp oil cannabis oil hemp cbd oil

  21. cbd oil for dogs cbd oil for pain cbd drops

  22. cbd for sale cbd drops cbd for dogs

  23. cbd oil at walmart cbd for dogs cbd pills cbd oil for dogs

  24. cbd gummies walmart http://cbdoilstore.us.com/ – hemp oil cbd hemp cbd capsules

  25. hemp oil http://cbdoilrx.us.com/ – hemp oil cdb oils cannabis oil

  26. cbd near me http://cbdoilstore.us.com/ – cbd for sale cbd hemp cbd oil store

  27. cbd near me http://cbd-store.us.com/ – cbd for sale cbd gummies walmart hemp oil

  28. hemp oil http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd oil at walmart cbd oil at walmart cbd for sale

  29. medterra cbd pure cbd oil cbd oil benefits cbd gummies walmart

  30. cbd oil http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd pills cbd medic cbd medic

  31. cbd hemp http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd oil for dogs cbd vape cbd oils

  32. buy cbd oil online hemp cbd cbd oil store cbd oil at walmart

  33. cbd oil store cbd oil for dogs cbd vape cdb oils

  34. cbd vape buy hemp oil cbd hemp buy hemp oil

  35. cbd drops medterra cbd cbd gummies

  36. buy cbd oil cbd for sale hemp oil for pain

  37. cbd cbd vape hemp cbd cbd products

  38. best cbd oil cbd cbd for dogs

  39. cdb oils cbd pure medterra cbd

  40. cbd oil online http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – cbd oil buy cbd oil online cbd products

  41. cbd products cbd pure buy cbd oil online best cbd oil

  42. hemp oil for pain hemp oil cbd oil for pain

  43. cbd gummies cbd vape cbd hemp

  44. cbd online http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – best cbd oil pure cbd oil pure cbd oil

  45. cbd oil for pain cbd medic cbd oil store hemp cbd

  46. cbd vape http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd for sale hemp cbd cbd cream

  47. cbd vape hemp cbd oil cbd drops cbd for sale

  48. cbd near me http://cbd-oils.us.com/ – cbd oil for pain hemp oil for pain cbd oil

  49. cbd oil for dogs http://cbd-store.us.com/ – cbd near me hemp cbd oil best cbd oil

  50. hemp oil for pain cbd oil for pain cbd oil benefits hemp cbd

  51. cbd oil store cbd store cbd pills

  52. buy cbd oil online cbd gummies walmart cbd oil benefits cbd vape

  53. cbd near me buy cbd oil online cbd oils cannabis oil

  54. cbd oil store cbd oil at walmart hemp cbd oil cbd oil for dogs

  55. best cbd oil cbd vape cbd oil for sale

  56. hemp cbd cbd oil for sale cbd oils hemp cbd

  57. best cbd oil buy cbd oil http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd for dogs cbd oil for pain cbd store

  58. cbd hemp http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd cream cbd oils buy cbd

  59. cbd oil online cbd drops cbd store cbd gummies walmart

  60. cbd near me http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – cbd gummies cbd for dogs hemp oil for pain

  61. cbd gummies http://cbd-store.us.com/ – cbd gummies cbd pills medterra cbd

  62. hemp oil for pain buy cbd buy hemp oil

  63. cbd oil at walmart http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd oil benefits cbd gummies best cbd oil

  64. cbd hemp http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd cbd tinctures cbd oil at walmart

  65. cbd vape cbd oil at walmart buy cbd cbd vape

  66. medterra cbd http://cbd-online.us.com/ – hemp oil cbd gummies walmart cbd oil at walmart

  67. buy hemp oil http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – buy cbd oil cbd cream cbd oil for pain

  68. cbd medic cbd near me cbd pills cbd

  69. cbd vape cbd for sale cbd tinctures cbd for sale

  70. cbd oil for dogs cbd for sale cbd store cbd oil online

  71. hemp cbd http://cbd-store.us.com/ – hemp oil cbd capsules buy cbd oil

  72. pure cbd oil cbd near me cbd hemp

  73. buy cbd cbd oil for sale cbd tinctures cbd oil at walmart

  74. best cbd oil http://cbd-online.us.com/ – buy cbd oil cbd oil online buy cbd

  75. hemp cbd buy hemp oil cbd oil store

  76. cbd pure http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd for sale cbd online buy cbd

  77. best cbd oil buy cbd oil best cbd oil buy cbd

  78. medterra cbd cbd oil benefits cbd vape cbd capsules

  79. cbd for dogs cbd oils cbd gummies hemp oil

  80. best cbd oil buy cbd oil online cbd for sale cbd online

  81. cbd for dogs cbd vape buy cbd

  82. cbd store http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – buy hemp oil cbd oil for sale cbd store

  83. cbd cream http://cbd-online.us.com/ – buy cbd cbd oil store cbd products

  84. cbd drops cbd oil benefits cbd oil store cbd pills

  85. hemp cbd hemp oil cbd oil benefits medterra cbd

  86. cbd oils hemp oil cbd oil for pain

  87. buy cbd oil online cbd hemp cbd buy cbd oil

  88. cbd oil benefits cbd oil benefits cbd oil at walmart cbd pure

  89. hemp oil for pain best cbd oil buy cbd oil cbd oil benefits

  90. cbd oil online buy cbd oil online cbd pure cbd oil

  91. cbd oil benefits hemp oil cbd medic cbd oil store

  92. buy cbd oil online hemp oil cbd online

  93. cbd oil online cbd medic cbd near me

  94. medterra cbd http://cbdoilinn.com/ – cbd products cbd tinctures cbd

  95. cbd near me cbd cream cbd gummies

  96. hemp oil http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – cbd oil store cbd gummies walmart cbd oils

  97. buy cbd oil http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd gummies cbd oil benefits cbd for sale

  98. cbd gummies walmart cbd tinctures hemp cbd

  99. cbd pure http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – hemp cbd cbd oil for sale cbd oil

  100. cbd online cbd oil at walmart cbd oil for sale

  101. cbd for sale cbd oil at walmart cbd vape cbd cream

  102. cbd oil for sale http://cbdoilinn.com/ – cbd tinctures cbd oil for sale buy cbd oil

  103. cbd vape cbd store cbd oil for pain cbd drops

  104. cbd oil for sale http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – hemp oil for pain cbd for dogs cbd products

  105. cbd for dogs buy cbd oil cbd cream cbd gummies

  106. cbd oil at walmart http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – cbd oil benefits cbd medic hemp cbd oil

  107. hemp oil http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd oil online cbd cream cbd online

  108. cbd pills cbd near me cbd oil for pain

  109. cbd oil for dogs cbd cream cbd pills

  110. cbd tinctures http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd hemp cdb oils cbd oil store

  111. cbd gummies walmart http://cbdoilinn.com/ – pure cbd oil cbd oil cbd capsules

  112. cbd oil online http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd oils cbd medic cbd near me

  113. cbd capsules http://cbd-online.us.com/ – buy cbd oil buy hemp oil cbd pure

  114. hemp oil for pain cbd near me hemp cbd oil

  115. cbd capsules cannabis oil medterra cbd

  116. buy cbd oil online cbd for dogs cbd drops cbd oil store

  117. buy hemp oil http://cbd-online.us.com/ – buy cbd oil cbd for dogs cbd near me

  118. hemp oil http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd oil store cbd pure cbd drops

  119. buy cbd http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd online hemp cbd oil cbd oil

  120. cbd pure cbd vape hemp oil medterra cbd

  121. cbd oil for sale cbd store hemp oil buy hemp oil

  122. cbd oil for dogs cannabis oil cbd for sale buy cbd

  123. cbd oil for pain cbd tinctures cbd pills cbd capsules

  124. hemp cbd oil cbd for dogs cannabis oil

  125. best cbd oil cbd oil for pain best cbd oil pure cbd oil

  126. medterra cbd cbd for dogs pure cbd oil

  127. cbd oil for sale http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – best cbd oil cbd oil online cbd pills

  128. cbd oil online cbd for dogs medterra cbd cbd oil for pain

  129. hemp cbd oil cbd tinctures cbd for dogs buy hemp oil

  130. best cbd oil cbd oil benefits cbd oil for dogs best cbd oil

  131. cbd oil for pain http://cbdoilinn.com/ – cbd near me cbd products cbd store

  132. cbd for sale cbd oil for sale cbd oil at walmart hemp cbd

  133. cbd vape cbd oil for sale cbd gummies cbd oil benefits

  134. hemp cbd http://cbdoilinn.com/ – cbd store cbd near me cbd oil store

  135. cbd oil store cbd products cbd oil online

  136. pure cbd oil cbd oil benefits medterra cbd cbd near me

  137. cbd http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – cbd hemp cbd oil for sale cbd oil at walmart

  138. medterra cbd http://cbd-store.us.com/ – cbd hemp cbd oil store cbd oils

  139. cbd oil for sale http://cbdoilinn.com/ – cbd pure pure cbd oil buy hemp oil

  140. cbd oil for dogs cbd capsules cbd oils hemp cbd

  141. cbd oil at walmart http://cbd-oils.us.com/ – cbd tinctures cbd for dogs cbd cream

  142. hemp cbd http://cbd-online.us.com/ – cbd oil cbd capsules buy cbd oil online

  143. cbd medic http://cbd-hemp.us.com/ – hemp cbd cbd oil for sale hemp oil

  144. cbd oils http://buycbdoilonline.us.com/ – cbd store cbd cbd cream

  145. cbd oil store cbd tinctures hemp oil cbd capsules

  146. buy cbd oil cbd near me buy cbd oil online cbd oil for sale

  147. hemp cbd oil cbd vape cbd oil for dogs cbd oils

  148. cbd capsules cbd online hemp cbd cbd drops

  149. pure cbd oil cbd for dogs buy cbd oil online

  150. credit rating check http://creditreportfxf.com/ – credit karma free credit report check credit score for free credit check

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *